Laminate vs. Solid Surface vs. Granite vs. Quartz: Which Countertop Is Right for You?
A look at four unique countertop materials, their pros, things to consider, and where they make a good fit.
Greg Goehring
EXPERT CONTRIBUTOR
Owner, Black Hills Countertops
Q: How do I choose the right countertop material for my home?
Choosing countertops is about more than finding a color or pattern you like. Budget, durability, maintenance, heat resistance and how you use the space can all play a role in determining which material makes the most sense for your kitchen or bathroom.
Laminate, solid surface, granite and quartz each have advantages and tradeoffs. Understanding the differences can make it easier to narrow down your options before you start shopping.
Laminate
Pros: Laminate is typically one of the most budget-friendly countertop choices and is available in a huge variety of colors, patterns and finishes. Today’s options can mimic the look of stone, wood and other higher-priced materials.
Things to consider: Laminate can be more susceptible to scratches, chips and heat damage than some other countertop materials. Seams and areas around sinks also require proper installation and care to help prevent moisture from reaching the material underneath.
A good fit for: Homeowners looking for an affordable countertop with plenty of design choices, as well as rental properties, laundry rooms and other budget-conscious projects.
Granite
Pros: Because granite is natural stone, every slab has its own variations in color and pattern. It’s durable, heat resistant and can provide the natural stone appearance many homeowners want.
Things to consider: Granite may require periodic sealing depending on the stone and finish. Because it is a natural material, colors and patterns aren’t completely uniform, and chips or cracks can sometimes be more complicated to repair.
A good fit for: Homeowners who appreciate natural stone, unique variations and a traditional or high-end appearance.
Quartz
Pros: Quartz countertops are engineered using natural quartz combined with resins and pigments. They’re nonporous, don’t require sealing and are available in a wide variety of colors and patterns. Their more consistent appearance can also make it easier to coordinate countertops throughout a space.
Things to consider: Quartz is generally a premium-priced option. Although durable, it can still chip or be damaged, and manufacturers typically recommend protecting the surface from excessive heat.
A good fit for: Homeowners looking for a durable, low-maintenance surface with consistent colors and patterns.
Solid Surface
Pros: Solid surface countertops are nonporous and available in many colors and styles. One of their distinctive features is the ability to create inconspicuous seams and integrated sinks for a smooth, continuous appearance. Scratches and some types of damage can also often be repaired or refinished rather than requiring replacement of the entire countertop.
Things to consider: Solid surface isn’t as resistant to heat or scratching as some stone products, so trivets and cutting boards are important. The finished look is also different from natural stone, which may be a consideration for homeowners who specifically want the variation found in granite.
A good fit for: Homeowners who value easy cleaning, design flexibility, repairability and a smooth, seamless appearance.
So, Which Countertop Should You Choose?
There isn’t one countertop material that’s best for every home. The right choice depends on your budget, the look you want and how the countertop will be used.
If keeping costs down is the priority, laminate may make the most sense. If you love the unique character of natural stone, granite may be worth considering. Quartz can be a good option when low maintenance and a consistent appearance are important, while solid surface offers advantages for homeowners interested in seamless designs and a surface that can often be repaired or refinished.
Before making a final decision, look at samples in person and talk with a countertop professional about how each material performs in the space you’re remodeling. A kitchen used by a busy family may have different needs than a guest bathroom, rental property or commercial space. The best countertop isn’t necessarily the most expensive one. It’s the one that fits the way you use your space.
Share This Article
More From Black Hills Countertops, Etc.
Join Our Newsletter
Local happenings, helpful information, and Black Hills finds.
